Max Caulfield is a terrible detective – I wish her all the best

If I am ever murdered, please do not ask Max Caulfield to investigate. I’ve already written our review for Life Is Strange: Double Exposure, in which I celebrated the touching moments of Max’s return to the series, and lamented the clunky plot that she finds herself in. In this adventure game, you’re looking into the killing of a close friend, shot by an unknown assailant. You hop between two dimensions to solve the case – one world in which your pal still lives and the other in which she’s dead. Unfortunately for the murder victim, you play a bona fide hot mess who could not perform a cross examination if she were standing in front of a crucifix with a magnifying glass.

Lots of spoilers for Double Exposure ahead – you’ve been warned.

A major theme of Life Is Strange is the inability to change the misfortunes of your life. Powers throughout the series are manifestations of trauma, a coping mechanism for all the stacking psychic damage that is smooshed upon protagonists like so much plot avocado on character toast.

Take Max. Her entire history is one of hurt. She witnesses a friend’s murder and is filled with regrets – she wants to alter the past and change the future. Daniel, the telekinetic child of Life Is Strange 2, also saw his father shot dead – he wants control over objects sufficient to stop a bullet. Alex in Life Is Strange: True Colors grew up in foster care – she is a psychic lightning rod for other people’s fear, rage, and sorrow, while being reluctant to embrace those emotions in herself.

This power-analogising of humanity’s psychological hangups (the engine that gives Life Is Strange stories much of their weight) continues in Double Exposure. In a later episode, we find out that Safi (the murdered woman) has her own power: the ability to shapeshift and mimic others. Long story short, it seems to be the result of an image-obsessed mother pushing her daughter to be perfect in the wake of her father leaving.

Max enters an abandoned building.

Image credit: Rock Paper Shotgun / Square Enix

Even though a lot of the storytelling in Double Exposure often confounds me, you can clearly see emotional introspection is what drives the game. These people are broken, but in that brokenness is beauty and resilience. They are kintsugi people. “What if I like the way my scars define me?” asks Max in a sardonic tone after seeing a self-help book on a bedside table. “What if they give me character?” She’s being snarky about it, as anyone cursed with nosebleeds and time travel might be. But in a way, she’s not wrong. You can’t undo a trauma, but you can choose to look at it as a scar that turns to gold.

All of this well-observed and psychologically literate characterisation is great. It also makes the ridiculous shit that characters do or say in Double Exposure mildly frustrating.

A piece of paper hangs out of a briefcase, and instead of just yanking it out the rest of the way, Max goes on a dimension-dipping prankathon to get the briefcase key. She tells people to go away instead of questioning them more fully on the weird things they saw. She routinely neglects to call or text her friends to fact check. I don’t know what is happening in her brain.

She doesn’t lead with the most urgent questions, but gets herself caught up in mundane tasks. Did I really need to go snoop on two secret society members before asking two-legged hair gel advertisement Vinh about a recent act of vandalism? No. He was standing right there the entire time. Max could have just asked. She is a terrible detective. She is Veronica Mars, if Veronica Mars were an alien who loves human crime shows yet had never been to earth.

A small-town detective vents his frustrations with Max.

Image credit: Rock Paper Shotgun / Square Enix

At one point, Max plots to expose a professor as a charlatan. He has plagiarised a student’s novel wholesale. She will out him as a fraud by using a projector to broadcast proof (a photo of the manuscripts side-by-side) at a public event. Together with Safi, she goes to great lengths to prep the projector, recruit fellow conspirators, and confront the man in person. All this instead of, say, posting said photos on the game’s equivalent of Twitter.

The implausible lack of communication that happens in the game is probably the most irritating. If you were given the ability to talk to the deceased in a murder case, you might sit them down for hours and go through everything in their personal and professional life to understand what’s going on. Max asks a single question about what enemies Safi might have, and then basically ignores her. In an investigation, your first instinct may be to go to the source. Max goes to every puddle of muddy water except the source.

Double Exposure constantly seeks to invest you in the reality of its world, yet there is barely any sense to the way Max behaves as a person. She is very often a flimsy piece of narrative fabric, stretched, bent, and folded into whatever shape the plot or gameplay demands. She constantly takes insensible actions, and jams herself into black and white decision-making before actually knowing anything hard or fast about the world around her.

It’s hard to know what went on at Deck Nine to result in such messiness, but judging by the studio’s recent history – much of it affecting its narrative department – it’s easy to imagine internal disagreements about the script and its direction throwing the entire story into some difficult pools of narrative goo. I don’t envy any writer who has to revive a beloved character in the face of increasing fan hostility never mind untold office toxicity and crunch.

Safi and Max rest on a bench in the winter weather.

Image credit: Rock Paper Shotgun / Square Enix

Still, for all this character’s inconsistencies, I can’t bring myself to dislike the dorky twit. Double Exposure is largely about revisiting a trauma, being unable to escape from it, but perhaps able to stare it down. It’s a reminder that poor Max, for all her plot-necessitated puppetry, has been through some hideously dark shit. At one point, there is a surreal dream sequence that sees you travelling through motel rooms, identical save for the books on the side table. One book is called “Gutshot” – no prizes for guessing what that refers to (it’s not the excellent collection of short stories by Amelia Gray though). By the third or fourth motel room, dressers and lamps flatten into the walls, made two-dimensional by the weight of wanting to forget. A reminder of the years Max spent running from her past. Everything goes black and white. A desire to sleep, to numb out, overtakes everything.

This is what I meant in my review when I explained it was a sequel of “ambivalence”. Max is both a well-realised human dealing with terrible memories, and an awful finder-outer of facts. She is able to step into her fears and confront her worst horrors, yet unable to send a text saying: “yo, did you know someone called Maya?”. She can bumrush a cerebrally horrendous hurricane of the past, yet is unable to surreptitiously check more than 2 emails in any given stranger’s inbox at a time. She is an accident of wacky plot, and the result of some keen character writing. I really hope she gets the healing she deserves. Because if anyone else dies around her, I’m calling the actual police. And I hate those guys.

Leave a Comment

url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url url